Best hotels in Key West
Best hotels in Key West: the best-rated on Staylist is The Marquesa Hotel (AI score 9.1, typically $332 a night); the best-rated under $350 is Island City House (AI score 8.7, typically $324 a night). Staylist lists 31 hotels in Key West, United States, each with a booking link.
More about hotels in Key West
Across the 31 with a previously observed price, typical nightly rates run from about $247 to $374, with the middle around $324. Of the 26 with listed amenities, common ones include wi-fi in public areas (85%), outdoor swimming pool (77%), private parking (69%), restaurant (69%). Guests most often mention great rooms, great swimming pool, clean pool.
Good for your kind of trip
From Staylist's AI overviews: the best-ranked hotels that suit each kind of trip.
Couples
- The Marquesa HotelMarquesa's Key West oasis
- Island City HouseIsland City House's calm
- The Perry Hotel & Marina Key WestThe Perry's marina vibes
Families
- Sunset Key CottagesSunset Key's island activities
- Hyatt Vacation Club at Windward PointeWindward Pointe's plane views
- Hyatt Vacation Club at Sunset HarborSunset Harbor's Key West perch
Beach and relaxation
- Sunset Key CottagesSunset Key's island activities
- The Perry Hotel & Marina Key WestThe Perry's marina vibes
- Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and SpaHyatt Centric Key West's dock
- 19.1The Marquesa Hotel3-star$332 / night
- 29.1Sunset Key Cottages4-star$1,090 / night
- 38.7Island City House3-star$324 / night
- 48.9The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West4-star$295 / night
- 58.8Hyatt Vacation Club at Windward Pointe3-star$465 / night
- 68.6Ellas Cottages - Key West Historic Inns4-star$288 / night
- 78.2Weatherstation Inn Circa 19113-star$222 / night
- 88.9Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa4-star$365 / night
- 98.4Ocean Key Resort & Spa, a Noble House Resort4-star$371 / night
- 108.8The Pier House Resort4-star · One Duval Street$359 / night
- 118.0Hyatt Vacation Club at Beach House3-star$422 / night
- 128.7Opal Key Resort & Marina4-star$381 / night
- 138.8La Concha Key West4-star$319 / night
- 148.1The Laureate Key West3-star$173 / night
- 158.9Hyatt Vacation Club at Sunset Harbor3-star$325 / night
- 168.6Havana Cabana at Key West4-star · FL$275 / night
- 177.4The Marker Key West Harbor Resort4-star$374 / night
- 187.8The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection4-star$381 / night
- 199.1Parrot Key Hotel & Villas4-star$225 / night
- 207.5Winslows Bungalows - Key West Historic Inns4-star$364 / night
- 219.0Southernmost Beach Resort4-star$310 / night
- 227.6Margaritaville Beach House Key West4-star$288 / night
- 236.9DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel Grand Key - Key West4-star$244 / night
- 248.6Beachside Resort & Residences3-star$268 / night
- 257.1Courtyard Key West Waterfront3-star$219 / night
- 267.7Ridley House - Key West Historic Inns3-star$405 / night
- 276.8Fitch Lodge - Key West Historic InnsKey West$195 / nightNo photo yet
- 286.8Blue Flamingo Resort Key WestKey West$198 / nightNo photo yet
- 296.5The Reach Key West, Curio Collection by HiltonKey West$403 / nightNo photo yet
- 306.4Hilton Garden Inn Key West/The Keys CollectionKey West$247 / nightNo photo yet
- 316.0Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection by HiltonKey West$443 / nightNo photo yet
Previously observed price; confirm current price and availability. Data updated 2 October 2026. How Staylist ranks hotels.